Modern Left

Share this post

User's avatar
Modern Left
The slaughter of the sacred cows?

The slaughter of the sacred cows?

Newsletter

Simon Fletcher's avatar
Simon Fletcher
Apr 29, 2022
∙ Paid

Share this post

User's avatar
Modern Left
The slaughter of the sacred cows?
Share

Labour and public ownership

What has happened to the slaughter of the Corbynite sacred cows? A City AM exclusive in February reported:

“Starmer is expected to ‘slaughter the sacred cows of Corbynism’ in the lead-up to summer, with speculation this could soon include ditching the former Labour leader’s pledges to nationalise rail, mail, energy and water.’

Twitter avatar for @Stefan_Boscia
Stefan Boscia @Stefan_Boscia
EXCL Starmer will try to definitively distance himself from Labour’s far-left 2019 election manifesto in a series of key speeches over the next few months. One senior Labour source says Starmer will "slaughter sacred cows of Corbynism" via @CityAM
cityam.comExclusive: Starmer to back away from 2019 Labour manifesto with series of key speechesSir Keir Starmer will try to definitively distance himself from Labour’s far-left 2019 election manifesto in a series of key speeches over the next few
5:42 PM ∙ Feb 17, 2022
235Likes59Retweets

At the time, many insiders felt the briefing bore a striking similarity to comments attributed to Wes Streeting at a Shadow Cabinet meeting last autumn:

“Sources say Right-winger Wes Streeting told a Shadow Cabinet meeting: ‘Every day, we should drag a sacred cow of our party to the town market place and slaughter it until we are up to our knees in blood.’ “

Grim.

But since that City AM report things have gone a little quiet. Perhaps it seemed poor timing to go on a policy offensive when the Tories were on the back foot over partygate, and at a time when Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has understandably dominated politics.

However, there are rumours within Labour ranks at Westminster that some senior party figures did indeed seek to persuade the Labour leadership to roll out a series of eye-catching changes to policy, in order to ditch key policies on public ownership and the economy - but that it reached an impasse.

On rail, different noises have so far emerged. The Shadow Transport secretary Lou Haigh told the March edition of Aslef journal:

‘Privatisation has been an absolute failure for rail – it’s failed taxpayers, it’s failed workers, and it’s failed passengers. The Williams-Shapps Review is a litany of failure, a long list of problems, caused by privatisation, and the fragmentation of our railway network.

‘We are totally committed to public ownership and to putting passengers back at the heart of decision making.’

Twitter avatar for @ASLEFunion
ASLEF @ASLEFunion
The March issue of the ASLEF Journal is now available, featuring an interview with Shadow Transport Secretary @LouHaigh who sets out her commitment to a publicly owned and operated railway:
aslef.org.ukASLEF Journal - March 2022 | ASLEFLou Haigh - Labour is Committed to Public Ownership of the Railway
1:53 PM ∙ Mar 8, 2022
11Likes8Retweets

Writing for this blog, also in March, TSSA general secretary Manuel Cortes said of the Labour Party:

“On transport, at least, it seems they are now resolute in support of public ownership.”

But if rail can be resolved satisfactorily, it would still leave many other elements of public ownership policy where a sharp shift rightwards would be possible. The ‘at least’ in Manuel Cortes’ comment is important. Once the May elections are over and the party faces towards conference in the autumn, we ought to expect this debate to heat up.


Mail misogyny

Unfortunately the last few days have reminded us that the next general election will be brutal.

The Mail on Sunday’s sexist hit-job on Angela Rayner last weekend instantaneously backfired. Strikingly, many journalists were some of the first to condemn it. The ferocity of the response meant that even Boris Johnson felt he had to ‘deplore’ the misogyny directed at Labour’s deputy leader.

While the episode has rightly sparked a new discussion about misogyny towards women in politics – and the classism that Angela Rayner herself has talked about – it has not also included any humility from the Mail itself. Quite the opposite.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Simon Fletcher
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share